Showing 61 of 61 total issues
Tweakphoeus::Client#initialize has boolean parameter 'redirect' Open
def initialize(ua_systems: %i[linux mac], ssl_verifypeer: true, redirect: false)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Boolean Parameter
is a special case of Control Couple
, where a method parameter is defaulted to true or false. A Boolean Parameter effectively permits a method's caller to decide which execution path to take. This is a case of bad cohesion. You're creating a dependency between methods that is not really necessary, thus increasing coupling.
Example
Given
class Dummy
def hit_the_switch(switch = true)
if switch
puts 'Hitting the switch'
# do other things...
else
puts 'Not hitting the switch'
# do other things...
end
end
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
test.rb -- 3 warnings:
[1]:Dummy#hit_the_switch has boolean parameter 'switch' (BooleanParameter)
[2]:Dummy#hit_the_switch is controlled by argument switch (ControlParameter)
Note that both smells are reported, Boolean Parameter
and Control Parameter
.
Getting rid of the smell
This is highly dependent on your exact architecture, but looking at the example above what you could do is:
- Move everything in the
if
branch into a separate method - Move everything in the
else
branch into a separate method - Get rid of the
hit_the_switch
method alltogether - Make the decision what method to call in the initial caller of
hit_the_switch
Tweakphoeus::CookieJar#parse_cookie has approx 6 statements Open
def parse_cookie(string)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A method with Too Many Statements
is any method that has a large number of lines.
Too Many Statements
warns about any method that has more than 5 statements. Reek's smell detector for Too Many Statements
counts +1 for every simple statement in a method and +1 for every statement within a control structure (if
, else
, case
, when
, for
, while
, until
, begin
, rescue
) but it doesn't count the control structure itself.
So the following method would score +6 in Reek's statement-counting algorithm:
def parse(arg, argv, &error)
if !(val = arg) and (argv.empty? or /\A-/ =~ (val = argv[0]))
return nil, block, nil # +1
end
opt = (val = parse_arg(val, &error))[1] # +2
val = conv_arg(*val) # +3
if opt and !arg
argv.shift # +4
else
val[0] = nil # +5
end
val # +6
end
(You might argue that the two assigments within the first @if@ should count as statements, and that perhaps the nested assignment should count as +2.)
Tweakphoeus::Client has at least 7 instance variables Open
class Client
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Too Many Instance Variables
is a special case of LargeClass
.
Example
Given this configuration
TooManyInstanceVariables:
max_instance_variables: 3
and this code:
class TooManyInstanceVariables
def initialize
@arg_1 = :dummy
@arg_2 = :dummy
@arg_3 = :dummy
@arg_4 = :dummy
end
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
test.rb -- 5 warnings:
[1]:TooManyInstanceVariables has at least 4 instance variables (TooManyInstanceVariables)
Tweakphoeus::Client#initialize has boolean parameter 'ssl_verifypeer' Open
def initialize(ua_systems: %i[linux mac], ssl_verifypeer: true, redirect: false)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Boolean Parameter
is a special case of Control Couple
, where a method parameter is defaulted to true or false. A Boolean Parameter effectively permits a method's caller to decide which execution path to take. This is a case of bad cohesion. You're creating a dependency between methods that is not really necessary, thus increasing coupling.
Example
Given
class Dummy
def hit_the_switch(switch = true)
if switch
puts 'Hitting the switch'
# do other things...
else
puts 'Not hitting the switch'
# do other things...
end
end
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
test.rb -- 3 warnings:
[1]:Dummy#hit_the_switch has boolean parameter 'switch' (BooleanParameter)
[2]:Dummy#hit_the_switch is controlled by argument switch (ControlParameter)
Note that both smells are reported, Boolean Parameter
and Control Parameter
.
Getting rid of the smell
This is highly dependent on your exact architecture, but looking at the example above what you could do is:
- Move everything in the
if
branch into a separate method - Move everything in the
else
branch into a separate method - Get rid of the
hit_the_switch
method alltogether - Make the decision what method to call in the initial caller of
hit_the_switch
Tweakphoeus::CookieJar#cookie_string has approx 8 statements Open
def cookie_string(url, headers = {})
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A method with Too Many Statements
is any method that has a large number of lines.
Too Many Statements
warns about any method that has more than 5 statements. Reek's smell detector for Too Many Statements
counts +1 for every simple statement in a method and +1 for every statement within a control structure (if
, else
, case
, when
, for
, while
, until
, begin
, rescue
) but it doesn't count the control structure itself.
So the following method would score +6 in Reek's statement-counting algorithm:
def parse(arg, argv, &error)
if !(val = arg) and (argv.empty? or /\A-/ =~ (val = argv[0]))
return nil, block, nil # +1
end
opt = (val = parse_arg(val, &error))[1] # +2
val = conv_arg(*val) # +3
if opt and !arg
argv.shift # +4
else
val[0] = nil # +5
end
val # +6
end
(You might argue that the two assigments within the first @if@ should count as statements, and that perhaps the nested assignment should count as +2.)
Tweakphoeus::RefererList#referer_from_headers refers to 'headers' more than self (maybe move it to another class?) Open
@referer.last.replace(headers['Referer']) if headers && headers['Referer'].is_a?(String)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Feature Envy occurs when a code fragment references another object more often than it references itself, or when several clients do the same series of manipulations on a particular type of object.
Feature Envy reduces the code's ability to communicate intent: code that "belongs" on one class but which is located in another can be hard to find, and may upset the "System of Names" in the host class.
Feature Envy also affects the design's flexibility: A code fragment that is in the wrong class creates couplings that may not be natural within the application's domain, and creates a loss of cohesion in the unwilling host class.
Feature Envy often arises because it must manipulate other objects (usually its arguments) to get them into a useful form, and one force preventing them (the arguments) doing this themselves is that the common knowledge lives outside the arguments, or the arguments are of too basic a type to justify extending that type. Therefore there must be something which 'knows' about the contents or purposes of the arguments. That thing would have to be more than just a basic type, because the basic types are either containers which don't know about their contents, or they are single objects which can't capture their relationship with their fellows of the same type. So, this thing with the extra knowledge should be reified into a class, and the utility method will most likely belong there.
Example
Running Reek on:
class Warehouse
def sale_price(item)
(item.price - item.rebate) * @vat
end
end
would report:
Warehouse#total_price refers to item more than self (FeatureEnvy)
since this:
(item.price - item.rebate)
belongs to the Item class, not the Warehouse.
Tweakphoeus::CookieJar#obtain_cookies has approx 6 statements Open
def obtain_cookies(response)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A method with Too Many Statements
is any method that has a large number of lines.
Too Many Statements
warns about any method that has more than 5 statements. Reek's smell detector for Too Many Statements
counts +1 for every simple statement in a method and +1 for every statement within a control structure (if
, else
, case
, when
, for
, while
, until
, begin
, rescue
) but it doesn't count the control structure itself.
So the following method would score +6 in Reek's statement-counting algorithm:
def parse(arg, argv, &error)
if !(val = arg) and (argv.empty? or /\A-/ =~ (val = argv[0]))
return nil, block, nil # +1
end
opt = (val = parse_arg(val, &error))[1] # +2
val = conv_arg(*val) # +3
if opt and !arg
argv.shift # +4
else
val[0] = nil # +5
end
val # +6
end
(You might argue that the two assigments within the first @if@ should count as statements, and that perhaps the nested assignment should count as +2.)
Tweakphoeus::Client#get has 4 parameters Open
def get(url, body: nil, params: nil, headers: nil)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A Long Parameter List
occurs when a method has a lot of parameters.
Example
Given
class Dummy
def long_list(foo,bar,baz,fling,flung)
puts foo,bar,baz,fling,flung
end
end
Reek would report the following warning:
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[2]:Dummy#long_list has 5 parameters (LongParameterList)
A common solution to this problem would be the introduction of parameter objects.
Tweakphoeus::Client#http_request has 5 parameters Open
def http_request(url, body: nil, params: nil, headers: nil, method: :get)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A Long Parameter List
occurs when a method has a lot of parameters.
Example
Given
class Dummy
def long_list(foo,bar,baz,fling,flung)
puts foo,bar,baz,fling,flung
end
end
Reek would report the following warning:
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[2]:Dummy#long_list has 5 parameters (LongParameterList)
A common solution to this problem would be the introduction of parameter objects.
Complex method Tweakphoeus::CookieJar#obtain_cookies (23.9) Open
def obtain_cookies(response)
set_cookies_field = [response.headers['Set-Cookie']].compact
set_cookies_field.each do |cookie|
key, value = cookie.match(/^([^=]+)=(.+)/).to_a[1..]
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Flog calculates the ABC score for methods. The ABC score is based on assignments, branches (method calls), and conditions.
You can read more about ABC metrics or the flog tool
Tweakphoeus::CookieJar#set_cookie calls '@cookie_jar[domain]' 3 times Open
@cookie_jar[domain] ||= {}
value = value.split(';').first
if value == '""'
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Duplication occurs when two fragments of code look nearly identical, or when two fragments of code have nearly identical effects at some conceptual level.
Reek implements a check for Duplicate Method Call.
Example
Here's a very much simplified and contrived example. The following method will report a warning:
def double_thing()
@other.thing + @other.thing
end
One quick approach to silence Reek would be to refactor the code thus:
def double_thing()
thing = @other.thing
thing + thing
end
A slightly different approach would be to replace all calls of double_thing
by calls to @other.double_thing
:
class Other
def double_thing()
thing + thing
end
end
The approach you take will depend on balancing other factors in your code.
Tweakphoeus::RefererList#referer_from_headers calls 'headers['Referer']' 2 times Open
@referer.last.replace(headers['Referer']) if headers && headers['Referer'].is_a?(String)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Duplication occurs when two fragments of code look nearly identical, or when two fragments of code have nearly identical effects at some conceptual level.
Reek implements a check for Duplicate Method Call.
Example
Here's a very much simplified and contrived example. The following method will report a warning:
def double_thing()
@other.thing + @other.thing
end
One quick approach to silence Reek would be to refactor the code thus:
def double_thing()
thing = @other.thing
thing + thing
end
A slightly different approach would be to replace all calls of double_thing
by calls to @other.double_thing
:
class Other
def double_thing()
thing + thing
end
end
The approach you take will depend on balancing other factors in your code.
Tweakphoeus::CookieJar#add_cookies calls '@cookie_jar[domain]' 2 times Open
@cookie_jar[domain] ||= {}
@cookie_jar[domain][key] = value
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Duplication occurs when two fragments of code look nearly identical, or when two fragments of code have nearly identical effects at some conceptual level.
Reek implements a check for Duplicate Method Call.
Example
Here's a very much simplified and contrived example. The following method will report a warning:
def double_thing()
@other.thing + @other.thing
end
One quick approach to silence Reek would be to refactor the code thus:
def double_thing()
thing = @other.thing
thing + thing
end
A slightly different approach would be to replace all calls of double_thing
by calls to @other.double_thing
:
class Other
def double_thing()
thing + thing
end
end
The approach you take will depend on balancing other factors in your code.
Tweakphoeus::UserAgent#browser calls 'Random.rand(0..9)' 2 times Open
webkit603 = "603.#{Random.rand(0..9)}.#{Random.rand(0..9)}"
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Duplication occurs when two fragments of code look nearly identical, or when two fragments of code have nearly identical effects at some conceptual level.
Reek implements a check for Duplicate Method Call.
Example
Here's a very much simplified and contrived example. The following method will report a warning:
def double_thing()
@other.thing + @other.thing
end
One quick approach to silence Reek would be to refactor the code thus:
def double_thing()
thing = @other.thing
thing + thing
end
A slightly different approach would be to replace all calls of double_thing
by calls to @other.double_thing
:
class Other
def double_thing()
thing + thing
end
end
The approach you take will depend on balancing other factors in your code.
Tweakphoeus::Client#redirect_url doesn't depend on instance state (maybe move it to another class?) Open
def redirect_url(response)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A Utility Function is any instance method that has no dependency on the state of the instance.
Tweakphoeus::Client#base_headers is a writable attribute Open
attr_accessor :cookie_jar, :referer_list, :base_headers, :redirect
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A class that publishes a setter for an instance variable invites client classes to become too intimate with its inner workings, and in particular with its representation of state.
The same holds to a lesser extent for getters, but Reek doesn't flag those.
Example
Given:
class Klass
attr_accessor :dummy
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
reek test.rb
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[2]:Klass declares the writable attribute dummy (Attribute)
Tweakphoeus::Client#redirect? performs a nil-check Open
!redirect_url(response).nil?
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A NilCheck
is a type check. Failures of NilCheck
violate the "tell, don't ask" principle.
Additionally, type checks often mask bigger problems in your source code like not using OOP and / or polymorphism when you should.
Example
Given
class Klass
def nil_checker(argument)
if argument.nil?
puts "argument isn't nil!"
end
end
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[3]:Klass#nil_checker performs a nil-check. (NilCheck)
Tweakphoeus::Client#build_base_headers doesn't depend on instance state (maybe move it to another class?) Open
def build_base_headers(ua_systems)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A Utility Function is any instance method that has no dependency on the state of the instance.
Tweakphoeus::Helpers#get_domain doesn't depend on instance state (maybe move it to another class?) Open
def get_domain(domain)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A Utility Function is any instance method that has no dependency on the state of the instance.
Tweakphoeus::Client#cookie_jar is a writable attribute Open
attr_accessor :cookie_jar, :referer_list, :base_headers, :redirect
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A class that publishes a setter for an instance variable invites client classes to become too intimate with its inner workings, and in particular with its representation of state.
The same holds to a lesser extent for getters, but Reek doesn't flag those.
Example
Given:
class Klass
attr_accessor :dummy
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
reek test.rb
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[2]:Klass declares the writable attribute dummy (Attribute)