phpmyadmin/phpmyadmin

View on GitHub
src/Advisory/Rules.php

Summary

Maintainability
F
6 days
Test Coverage
<?php

declare(strict_types=1);

namespace PhpMyAdmin\Advisory;

use function __;

/**
 * @psalm-type RuleType = array{
 *     id: non-empty-string,
 *     name: string,
 *     precondition?: non-empty-string,
 *     formula: non-empty-string,
 *     test: non-empty-string,
 *     issue: string,
 *     recommendation: string,
 *     justification: string,
 *     justification_formula?: non-empty-string
 * }
 */
final class Rules
{
    /**
     * @return array<int, array<string, string>>
     * @psalm-return list<RuleType>
     */
    public static function getGeneric(): array
    {
        return [
            // Queries
            [
                'id' => 'Uptime below one day',
                'name' => __('Uptime below one day'),
                'formula' => 'Uptime',
                'test' => 'value < 86400',
                'issue' => __('Uptime is less than 1 day, performance tuning may not be accurate.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'To have more accurate averages it is recommended to let the server run for'
                    . ' longer than a day before running this analyzer',
                ),
                'justification' => __('The uptime is only %s'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_timespanFormat(Uptime)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Questions below 1,000',
                'name' => __('Questions below 1,000'),
                'formula' => 'Questions',
                'test' => 'value < 1000',
                'issue' => __(
                    'Fewer than 1,000 questions have been run against this server.'
                    . ' The recommendations may not be accurate.',
                ),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Let the server run for a longer time until it has executed a greater amount of queries.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Current amount of Questions: %s'),
                'justification_formula' => 'Questions',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Percentage of slow queries',
                'name' => __('Percentage of slow queries'),
                'precondition' => 'Questions > 0',
                'formula' => 'Slow_queries / Questions * 100',
                'test' => 'value >= 5',
                'issue' => __('There is a lot of slow queries compared to the overall amount of Queries.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'You might want to increase {long_query_time} or optimize the queries listed in the slow query log',
                ),
                'justification' => __('The slow query rate should be below 5%%, your value is %s%%.'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Slow query rate',
                'name' => __('Slow query rate'),
                'precondition' => 'Questions > 0',
                'formula' => '(Slow_queries / Questions * 100) / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 * 60 > 1',
                'issue' => __('There is a high percentage of slow queries compared to the server uptime.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'You might want to increase {long_query_time} or optimize the queries listed in the slow query log',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    'You have a slow query rate of %s per hour, you should have less than 1%% per hour.',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Long query time',
                'name' => __('Long query time'),
                'formula' => 'long_query_time',
                'test' => 'value >= 10',
                'issue' => __(
                    '{long_query_time} is set to 10 seconds or more,'
                    . ' thus only slow queries that take above 10 seconds are logged.',
                ),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'It is suggested to set {long_query_time} to a lower value, depending on your environment.'
                    . ' Usually a value of 1-5 seconds is suggested.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('long_query_time is currently set to %ds.'),
                'justification_formula' => 'value',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Slow query logging',
                'name' => __('Slow query logging'),
                'precondition' => 'PMA_MYSQL_INT_VERSION < 50600',
                'formula' => 'log_slow_queries',
                'test' => 'value == \'OFF\'',
                'issue' => __('The slow query log is disabled.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Enable slow query logging by setting {log_slow_queries} to \'ON\'.'
                    . ' This will help troubleshooting badly performing queries.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('log_slow_queries is set to \'OFF\''),
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Slow query logging',
                'name' => __('Slow query logging'),
                'precondition' => 'PMA_MYSQL_INT_VERSION >= 50600',
                'formula' => 'slow_query_log',
                'test' => 'value == \'OFF\'',
                'issue' => __('The slow query log is disabled.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Enable slow query logging by setting {slow_query_log} to \'ON\'.'
                    . ' This will help troubleshooting badly performing queries.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('slow_query_log is set to \'OFF\''),
            ],
            // Versions
            [
                'id' => 'Release Series',
                'name' => __('Release Series'),
                'formula' => 'version',
                'test' => 'substr(value,0,2) <= \'5.\' && substr(value,2,1) < 1',
                'issue' => __('The MySQL server version less than 5.1.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'You should upgrade, as MySQL 5.1 has improved performance, and MySQL 5.5 even more so.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Current version: %s'),
                'justification_formula' => 'value',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Minor Version',
                'name' => __('Minor Version'),
                'precondition' => '! fired(\'Release Series\')',
                'formula' => 'version',
                'test' => 'substr(value,0,2) <= \'5.\' && substr(value,2,1) <= 1 && substr(value,4,2) < 30',
                'issue' => __('Version less than 5.1.30 (the first GA release of 5.1).'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'You should upgrade, as recent versions of MySQL 5.1 have improved performance'
                    . ' and MySQL 5.5 even more so.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Current version: %s'),
                'justification_formula' => 'value',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Minor Version',
                'name' => __('Minor Version'),
                'precondition' => '! fired(\'Release Series\')',
                'formula' => 'version',
                'test' => 'substr(value,0,1) == 5 && substr(value,2,1) == 5 && substr(value,4,2) < 8',
                'issue' => __('Version less than 5.5.8 (the first GA release of 5.5).'),
                'recommendation' => __('You should upgrade, to a stable version of MySQL 5.5.'),
                'justification' => __('Current version: %s'),
                'justification_formula' => 'value',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Distribution',
                'name' => __('Distribution'),
                'formula' => 'version_comment',
                'test' => 'preg_match(\'/source/i\',value)',
                'issue' => __('Version is compiled from source, not a MySQL official binary.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'If you did not compile from source, you may be using a package modified by a distribution.'
                    . ' The MySQL manual only is accurate for official MySQL binaries,'
                    . ' not any package distributions (such as RedHat, Debian/Ubuntu etc).',
                ),
                'justification' => __('\'source\' found in version_comment'),
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Distribution',
                'name' => __('Distribution'),
                'formula' => 'version_comment',
                'test' => 'preg_match(\'/percona/i\',value)',
                'issue' => __('The MySQL manual only is accurate for official MySQL binaries.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Percona documentation is at <a href="https://www.percona.com/software/documentation/">'
                    . 'https://www.percona.com/software/documentation/</a>',
                ),
                'justification' => __('\'percona\' found in version_comment'),
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'MySQL Architecture',
                'name' => __('MySQL Architecture'),
                'formula' => 'system_memory',
                'test' => 'value > 3072*1024 && !preg_match(\'/64/\',version_compile_machine)'
                    . ' && !preg_match(\'/64/\',version_compile_os)',
                'issue' => __('MySQL is not compiled as a 64-bit package.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Your memory capacity is above 3 GiB (assuming the Server is on localhost),'
                    . ' so MySQL might not be able to access all of your memory.'
                    . ' You might want to consider installing the 64-bit version of MySQL.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Available memory on this host: %s'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_formatByteDown(value*1024, 2, 2)',
            ],
            // Query cache
            [
                'id' => 'Query caching method',
                'name' => __('Query caching method'),
                'precondition' => '!fired(\'Query cache disabled\')',
                'formula' => 'Questions / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value > 100',
                'issue' => __('Suboptimal caching method.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'You are using the MySQL Query cache with a fairly high traffic database.'
                    . ' It might be worth considering to use '
                    . '<a href="https://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.6/en/ha-memcached.html">memcached</a>'
                    . ' instead of the MySQL Query cache, especially if you have multiple replicas.',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    'The query cache is enabled and the server receives %d queries per second.'
                    . ' This rule fires if there is more than 100 queries per second.',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            // Sorts
            [
                'id' => 'Percentage of sorts that cause temporary tables',
                'name' => __('Percentage of sorts that cause temporary tables'),
                'precondition' => 'Sort_scan + Sort_range > 0',
                'formula' => 'Sort_merge_passes / (Sort_scan + Sort_range) * 100',
                'test' => 'value > 10',
                'issue' => __('Too many sorts are causing temporary tables.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Consider increasing {sort_buffer_size} and/or {read_rnd_buffer_size},'
                    . ' depending on your system memory limits.',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    '%s%% of all sorts cause temporary tables, this value should be lower than 10%%.',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Rate of sorts that cause temporary tables',
                'name' => __('Rate of sorts that cause temporary tables'),
                'formula' => 'Sort_merge_passes / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 * 60 > 1',
                'issue' => __('Too many sorts are causing temporary tables.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Consider increasing {sort_buffer_size} and/or {read_rnd_buffer_size},'
                    . ' depending on your system memory limits.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Temporary tables average: %s, this value should be less than 1 per hour.'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Sort rows',
                'name' => __('Sort rows'),
                'formula' => 'Sort_rows / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 >= 1',
                'issue' => __('There are lots of rows being sorted.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'While there is nothing wrong with a high amount of row sorting, you might want to'
                    . ' make sure that the queries which require a lot of sorting use indexed columns in'
                    . ' the ORDER BY clause, as this will result in much faster sorting.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Sorted rows average: %s'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            // Joins, scans
            [
                'id' => 'Rate of joins without indexes',
                'name' => __('Rate of joins without indexes'),
                'formula' => '(Select_range_check + Select_scan + Select_full_join) / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 * 60 > 1',
                'issue' => __('There are too many joins without indexes.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'This means that joins are doing full table scans. Adding indexes for the columns being'
                    . ' used in the join conditions will greatly speed up table joins.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Table joins average: %s, this value should be less than 1 per hour'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Rate of reading first index entry',
                'name' => __('Rate of reading first index entry'),
                'formula' => 'Handler_read_first / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 * 60 > 1',
                'issue' => __('The rate of reading the first index entry is high.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'This usually indicates frequent full index scans. Full index scans are faster than'
                    . ' table scans but require lots of CPU cycles in big tables, if those tables that have or'
                    . ' had high volumes of UPDATEs and DELETEs, running \'OPTIMIZE TABLE\' might reduce the'
                    . ' amount of and/or speed up full index scans. Other than that full index scans can'
                    . ' only be reduced by rewriting queries.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Index scans average: %s, this value should be less than 1 per hour'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Rate of reading fixed position',
                'name' => __('Rate of reading fixed position'),
                'formula' => 'Handler_read_rnd / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 * 60 > 1',
                'issue' => __('The rate of reading data from a fixed position is high.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'This indicates that many queries need to sort results and/or do a full table scan,'
                    . ' including join queries that do not use indexes. Add indexes where applicable.',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    'Rate of reading fixed position average: %s, this value should be less than 1 per hour',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Rate of reading next table row',
                'name' => __('Rate of reading next table row'),
                'formula' => 'Handler_read_rnd_next / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 * 60 > 1',
                'issue' => __('The rate of reading the next table row is high.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'This indicates that many queries are doing full table scans. Add indexes where applicable.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Rate of reading next table row: %s, this value should be less than 1 per hour'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            // Temp tables
            [
                'id' => 'Different tmp_table_size and max_heap_table_size',
                'name' => __('Different tmp_table_size and max_heap_table_size'),
                'formula' => 'tmp_table_size - max_heap_table_size',
                'test' => 'value !=0',
                'issue' => __('{tmp_table_size} and {max_heap_table_size} are not the same.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'If you have deliberately changed one of either: The server uses the lower value of either'
                    . ' to determine the maximum size of in-memory tables. So if you wish to increase the'
                    . ' in-memory table limit you will have to increase the other value as well.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Current values are tmp_table_size: %s, max_heap_table_size: %s'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_formatByteDown(tmp_table_size, 2, 2),'
                    . ' ADVISOR_formatByteDown(max_heap_table_size, 2, 2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Percentage of temp tables on disk',
                'name' => __('Percentage of temp tables on disk'),
                'precondition' => 'Created_tmp_tables + Created_tmp_disk_tables > 0',
                'formula' => 'Created_tmp_disk_tables / (Created_tmp_tables + Created_tmp_disk_tables) * 100',
                'test' => 'value > 25',
                'issue' => __('Many temporary tables are being written to disk instead of being kept in memory.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Increasing {max_heap_table_size} and {tmp_table_size} might help. However some'
                    . ' temporary tables are always being written to disk, independent of the value of these variables.'
                    . ' To eliminate these you will have to rewrite your queries to avoid those conditions'
                    . ' (Within a temporary table: Presence of a BLOB or TEXT column or presence of a column'
                    . ' bigger than 512 bytes) as mentioned in the beginning of an <a href="'
                    . 'https://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=10150111255065841&comments'
                    . '">Article by the Pythian Group</a>',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    '%s%% of all temporary tables are being written to disk, this value should be below 25%%',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Temp disk rate',
                'name' => __('Temp disk rate'),
                'precondition' => '!fired(\'Percentage of temp tables on disk\')',
                'formula' => 'Created_tmp_disk_tables / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 * 60 > 1',
                'issue' => __('Many temporary tables are being written to disk instead of being kept in memory.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Increasing {max_heap_table_size} and {tmp_table_size} might help. However some'
                    . ' temporary tables are always being written to disk, independent of the value of these variables.'
                    . ' To eliminate these you will have to rewrite your queries to avoid those conditions'
                    . ' (Within a temporary table: Presence of a BLOB or TEXT column or presence of a column'
                    . ' bigger than 512 bytes) as mentioned in the <a href="'
                    . 'https://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/8.0/en/internal-temporary-tables.html'
                    . '">MySQL Documentation</a>',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    'Rate of temporary tables being written to disk: %s, this value should be less than 1 per hour',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            // MyISAM index cache
            [
                'id' => 'MyISAM key buffer size',
                'name' => __('MyISAM key buffer size'),
                'formula' => 'key_buffer_size',
                'test' => 'value == 0',
                'issue' => __('Key buffer is not initialized. No MyISAM indexes will be cached.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Set {key_buffer_size} depending on the size of your MyISAM indexes. 64M is a good start.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('key_buffer_size is 0'),
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Max % MyISAM key buffer ever used',
                /* xgettext:no-php-format */
                'name' => __('Max % MyISAM key buffer ever used'),
                'precondition' => 'key_buffer_size > 0',
                'formula' => 'Key_blocks_used * key_cache_block_size / key_buffer_size * 100',
                'test' => 'value < 95',
                /* xgettext:no-php-format */
                'issue' => __('MyISAM key buffer (index cache) % used is low.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'You may need to decrease the size of {key_buffer_size}, re-examine your tables to see'
                    . ' if indexes have been removed, or examine queries and expectations'
                    . ' about what indexes are being used.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('max %% MyISAM key buffer ever used: %s%%, this value should be above 95%%'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Percentage of MyISAM key buffer used',
                'name' => __('Percentage of MyISAM key buffer used'),
                // Don't fire if above rule fired - we don't need the same advice twice
                'precondition' => 'key_buffer_size > 0 && !fired(\'Max % MyISAM key buffer ever used\')',
                'formula' => '( 1 - Key_blocks_unused * key_cache_block_size / key_buffer_size) * 100',
                'test' => 'value < 95',
                /* xgettext:no-php-format */
                'issue' => __('MyISAM key buffer (index cache) % used is low.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'You may need to decrease the size of {key_buffer_size}, re-examine your tables to see'
                    . ' if indexes have been removed, or examine queries and expectations'
                    . ' about what indexes are being used.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('%% MyISAM key buffer used: %s%%, this value should be above 95%%'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Percentage of index reads from memory',
                'name' => __('Percentage of index reads from memory'),
                'precondition' => 'Key_read_requests > 0',
                'formula' => '100 - (Key_reads / Key_read_requests * 100)',
                'test' => 'value < 95',
                /* xgettext:no-php-format */
                'issue' => __('The % of indexes that use the MyISAM key buffer is low.'),
                'recommendation' => __('You may need to increase {key_buffer_size}.'),
                'justification' => __('Index reads from memory: %s%%, this value should be above 95%%'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            // Other caches
            [
                'id' => 'Rate of table open',
                'name' => __('Rate of table open'),
                'formula' => 'Opened_tables / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value*60*60 > 10',
                'issue' => __('The rate of opening tables is high.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Opening tables requires disk I/O which is costly. Increasing {table_open_cache} might avoid this.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Opened table rate: %s, this value should be less than 10 per hour'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Percentage of used open files limit',
                'name' => __('Percentage of used open files limit'),
                'formula' => 'Open_files / open_files_limit * 100',
                'test' => 'value > 85',
                'issue' => __(
                    'The number of open files is approaching the max number of open files.'
                    . ' You may get a "Too many open files" error.',
                ),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Consider increasing {open_files_limit}, and check the error log when'
                    . ' restarting after changing {open_files_limit}.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('The number of opened files is at %s%% of the limit. It should be below 85%%'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Rate of open files',
                'name' => __('Rate of open files'),
                'formula' => 'Open_files / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 * 60 > 5',
                'issue' => __('The rate of opening files is high.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Consider increasing {open_files_limit}, and check the error log when'
                    . ' restarting after changing {open_files_limit}.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Opened files rate: %s, this value should be less than 5 per hour'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Immediate table locks %',
                /* xgettext:no-php-format */
                'name' => __('Immediate table locks %'),
                'precondition' => 'Table_locks_waited + Table_locks_immediate > 0',
                'formula' => 'Table_locks_immediate / (Table_locks_waited + Table_locks_immediate) * 100',
                'test' => 'value < 95',
                'issue' => __('Too many table locks were not granted immediately.'),
                'recommendation' => __('Optimize queries and/or use InnoDB to reduce lock wait.'),
                'justification' => __('Immediate table locks: %s%%, this value should be above 95%%'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Table lock wait rate',
                'name' => __('Table lock wait rate'),
                'formula' => 'Table_locks_waited / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 * 60 > 1',
                'issue' => __('Too many table locks were not granted immediately.'),
                'recommendation' => __('Optimize queries and/or use InnoDB to reduce lock wait.'),
                'justification' => __('Table lock wait rate: %s, this value should be less than 1 per hour'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Thread cache',
                'name' => __('Thread cache'),
                'formula' => 'thread_cache_size',
                'test' => 'value < 1',
                'issue' => __('Thread cache is disabled, resulting in more overhead from new connections to MySQL.'),
                'recommendation' => __('Enable the thread cache by setting {thread_cache_size} > 0.'),
                'justification' => __('The thread cache is set to 0'),
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Thread cache hit rate %',
                /* xgettext:no-php-format */
                'name' => __('Thread cache hit rate %'),
                'precondition' => 'thread_cache_size > 0',
                'formula' => '100 - Threads_created / Connections',
                'test' => 'value < 80',
                'issue' => __('Thread cache is not efficient.'),
                'recommendation' => __('Increase {thread_cache_size}.'),
                'justification' => __('Thread cache hitrate: %s%%, this value should be above 80%%'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Threads that are slow to launch',
                'name' => __('Threads that are slow to launch'),
                'precondition' => 'slow_launch_time > 0',
                'formula' => 'Slow_launch_threads',
                'test' => 'value > 0',
                'issue' => __('There are too many threads that are slow to launch.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'This generally happens in case of general system overload as it is pretty simple'
                    . ' operations. You might want to monitor your system load carefully.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('%s thread(s) took longer than %s seconds to start, it should be 0'),
                'justification_formula' => 'value, slow_launch_time',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Slow launch time',
                'name' => __('Slow launch time'),
                'formula' => 'slow_launch_time',
                'test' => 'value > 2',
                'issue' => __('Slow_launch_time is above 2s.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Set {slow_launch_time} to 1s or 2s to correctly count threads that are slow to launch.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('slow_launch_time is set to %s'),
                'justification_formula' => 'value',
            ],
            // Connections
            [
                'id' => 'Percentage of used connections',
                'name' => __('Percentage of used connections'),
                'formula' => 'Max_used_connections / max_connections * 100',
                'test' => 'value > 80',
                'issue' => __(
                    'The maximum amount of used connections is getting close to the value of {max_connections}.',
                ),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Increase {max_connections}, or decrease {wait_timeout} so that connections that do not'
                    . ' close database handlers properly get killed sooner.'
                    . ' Make sure the code closes database handlers properly.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Max_used_connections is at %s%% of max_connections, it should be below 80%%'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Percentage of aborted connections',
                'name' => __('Percentage of aborted connections'),
                'formula' => 'Aborted_connects / Connections * 100',
                'test' => 'value > 1',
                'issue' => __('Too many connections are aborted.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Connections are usually aborted when they cannot be authorized. <a href="'
                    . 'https://www.percona.com/blog/2008/08/23/how-to-track-down-the-source-of-aborted_connects/'
                    . '">This article</a> might help you track down the source.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('%s%% of all connections are aborted. This value should be below 1%%'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Rate of aborted connections',
                'name' => __('Rate of aborted connections'),
                'formula' => 'Aborted_connects / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 * 60 > 1',
                'issue' => __('Too many connections are aborted.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Connections are usually aborted when they cannot be authorized. <a href="'
                    . 'https://www.percona.com/blog/2008/08/23/how-to-track-down-the-source-of-aborted_connects/'
                    . '">This article</a> might help you track down the source.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Aborted connections rate is at %s, this value should be less than 1 per hour'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Percentage of aborted clients',
                'name' => __('Percentage of aborted clients'),
                'formula' => 'Aborted_clients / Connections * 100',
                'test' => 'value > 2',
                'issue' => __('Too many clients are aborted.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Clients are usually aborted when they did not close their connection to MySQL properly.'
                    . ' This can be due to network issues or code not closing a database handler properly.'
                    . ' Check your network and code.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('%s%% of all clients are aborted. This value should be below 2%%'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Rate of aborted clients',
                'name' => __('Rate of aborted clients'),
                'formula' => 'Aborted_clients / Uptime',
                'test' => 'value * 60 * 60 > 1',
                'issue' => __('Too many clients are aborted.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Clients are usually aborted when they did not close their connection to MySQL properly.'
                    . ' This can be due to network issues or code not closing a database handler properly.'
                    . ' Check your network and code.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Aborted client rate is at %s, this value should be less than 1 per hour'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_bytime(value,2)',
            ],
            // InnoDB
            [
                'id' => 'Is InnoDB disabled?',
                'name' => __('Is InnoDB disabled?'),
                'precondition' => 'PMA_MYSQL_INT_VERSION < 50600',
                'formula' => 'have_innodb',
                'test' => 'value != "YES"',
                'issue' => __('You do not have InnoDB enabled.'),
                'recommendation' => __('InnoDB is usually the better choice for table engines.'),
                'justification' => __('have_innodb is set to \'value\''),
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'InnoDB log size',
                'name' => __('InnoDB log size'),
                'precondition' => 'innodb_buffer_pool_size > 0 && ! (IS_MARIADB && PMA_MYSQL_INT_VERSION > 100500)',
                'formula' => '(innodb_log_file_size * innodb_log_files_in_group)/ innodb_buffer_pool_size * 100',
                'test' => 'value < 20 && innodb_log_file_size / (1024 * 1024) < 256',
                'issue' => __(
                    'The InnoDB log file size is not an appropriate size, in relation to the InnoDB buffer pool.',
                ),
                'recommendation' => __(/* xgettext:no-php-format */
                    'Especially on a system with a lot of writes to InnoDB tables you should set'
                    . ' {innodb_log_file_size} to 25% of {innodb_buffer_pool_size}. However the bigger this value,'
                    . ' the longer the recovery time will be when database crashes, so this value should not be set'
                    . ' much higher than 256 MiB. Please note however that you cannot simply change the value of'
                    . ' this variable. You need to shutdown the server, remove the InnoDB log files, set the new'
                    . ' value in my.cnf, start the server, then check the error logs if everything went fine.'
                    . ' See also <a href="'
                    . 'https://mysqldatabaseadministration.blogspot.com'
                    . '/2007/01/increase-innodblogfilesize-proper-way.html'
                    . '">this blog entry</a>',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    'Your InnoDB log size is at %s%% in relation to the InnoDB buffer pool size,'
                    . ' it should not be below 20%%',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'InnoDB log size',
                'name' => __('InnoDB log size'),
                'precondition' => 'innodb_buffer_pool_size > 0 && IS_MARIADB && PMA_MYSQL_INT_VERSION > 100500',
                // From MariaDB 10.5, there is 1 redo log.
                // For MariaDB 10.4 and before, the number of redo log files is configured
                // by the innodb_log_files_in_group system variable.
                'formula' => 'innodb_log_file_size / innodb_buffer_pool_size * 100',
                'test' => 'value < 20 && innodb_log_file_size / (1024 * 1024) < 256',
                'issue' => __(
                    'The InnoDB log file size is not an appropriate size, in relation to the InnoDB buffer pool.',
                ),
                'recommendation' => __(/* xgettext:no-php-format */
                    'Especially on a system with a lot of writes to InnoDB tables you should set'
                    . ' {innodb_log_file_size} to 25% of {innodb_buffer_pool_size}. However the bigger this value,'
                    . ' the longer the recovery time will be when database crashes, so this value should not be set'
                    . ' much higher than 256 MiB. Please note however that you cannot simply change the value of'
                    . ' this variable. You need to shutdown the server, remove the InnoDB log files, set the new'
                    . ' value in my.cnf, start the server, then check the error logs if everything went fine.'
                    . ' See also <a href="'
                    . 'https://mysqldatabaseadministration.blogspot.com'
                    . '/2007/01/increase-innodblogfilesize-proper-way.html'
                    . '">this blog entry</a>',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    'Your InnoDB log size is at %s%% in relation to the InnoDB buffer pool size,'
                    . ' it should not be below 20%%',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Max InnoDB log size',
                'name' => __('Max InnoDB log size'),
                'precondition' => 'innodb_buffer_pool_size > 0'
                    . ' && innodb_log_file_size / innodb_buffer_pool_size * 100 < 30',
                'formula' => 'innodb_log_file_size / (1024 * 1024)',
                'test' => 'value > 256',
                'issue' => __('The InnoDB log file size is inadequately large.'),
                'recommendation' => __(/* xgettext:no-php-format */
                    'It is usually sufficient to set {innodb_log_file_size} to 25% of the size of'
                    . ' {innodb_buffer_pool_size}. A very big {innodb_log_file_size} slows down the recovery'
                    . ' time after a database crash considerably. See also '
                    . '<a href="https://www.percona.com/blog/2006/07/03/choosing-proper-innodb_log_file_size/">'
                    . 'this Article</a>. You need to shutdown the server, remove the InnoDB log files, set the'
                    . ' new value in my.cnf, start the server, then check the error logs'
                    . ' if everything went fine. See also <a href="'
                    . 'https://mysqldatabaseadministration.blogspot.com'
                    . '/2007/01/increase-innodblogfilesize-proper-way.html'
                    . '">this blog entry</a>',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Your absolute InnoDB log size is %s MiB'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'InnoDB buffer pool size',
                'name' => __('InnoDB buffer pool size'),
                'precondition' => 'system_memory > 0',
                'formula' => 'innodb_buffer_pool_size / system_memory * 100',
                'test' => 'value < 60',
                'issue' => __('Your InnoDB buffer pool is fairly small.'),
                'recommendation' => __(/* xgettext:no-php-format */
                    'The InnoDB buffer pool has a profound impact on performance for InnoDB tables.'
                    . ' Assign all your remaining memory to this buffer. For database servers that use solely InnoDB'
                    . ' as storage engine and have no other services (e.g. a web server) running, you may set this'
                    . ' as high as 80% of your available memory. If that is not the case, you need to carefully'
                    . ' assess the memory consumption of your other services and non-InnoDB-Tables and set this'
                    . ' variable accordingly. If it is set too high, your system will start swapping,'
                    . ' which decreases performance significantly. See also <a href="'
                    . 'https://www.percona.com/blog/2007/11/03/choosing-innodb_buffer_pool_size/">this article</a>',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    'You are currently using %s%% of your memory for the InnoDB buffer pool.'
                    . ' This rule fires if you are assigning less than 60%%, however this might be perfectly'
                    . ' adequate for your system if you don\'t have much InnoDB tables'
                    . ' or other services running on the same machine.',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'value',
            ],
            // Other
            [
                'id' => 'MyISAM concurrent inserts',
                'name' => __('MyISAM concurrent inserts'),
                'formula' => 'concurrent_insert',
                'test' => 'value === 0 || value === \'NEVER\'',
                'issue' => __('Enable {concurrent_insert} by setting it to 1'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Setting {concurrent_insert} to 1 reduces contention between'
                    . ' readers and writers for a given table. See also <a'
                    . ' href="https://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.5/en/concurrent-inserts.html">MySQL Documentation</a>',
                ),
                'justification' => __('concurrent_insert is set to 0'),
            ],
        ];
    }

    /**
     * @return array<int, array<string, string>>
     * @psalm-return list<RuleType>
     */
    public static function getBeforeMySql80003(): array
    {
        return [
            // Query cache
            [
                'id' => 'Query cache disabled',
                'name' => __('Query cache disabled'),
                'formula' => 'query_cache_size',
                'test' => 'value == 0 || query_cache_type == \'OFF\' || query_cache_type == \'0\'',
                'issue' => __('The query cache is not enabled.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'The query cache is known to greatly improve performance if configured correctly. Enable it by'
                    . ' setting {query_cache_size} to a 2 digit MiB value and setting {query_cache_type} to \'ON\'.'
                    . ' <b>Note:</b> If you are using memcached, ignore this recommendation.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('query_cache_size is set to 0 or query_cache_type is set to \'OFF\''),
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Query cache efficiency (%)',
                /* xgettext:no-php-format */
                'name' => __('Query cache efficiency (%)'),
                'precondition' => 'Com_select + Qcache_hits > 0 && !fired(\'Query cache disabled\')',
                'formula' => 'Qcache_hits / (Com_select + Qcache_hits) * 100',
                'test' => 'value  < 20',
                'issue' => __('Query cache not running efficiently, it has a low hit rate.'),
                'recommendation' => __('Consider increasing {query_cache_limit}.'),
                'justification' => __('The current query cache hit rate of %s%% is below 20%%'),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Query Cache usage',
                'name' => __('Query Cache usage'),
                'precondition' => '!fired(\'Query cache disabled\')',
                'formula' => '100 - Qcache_free_memory / query_cache_size * 100',
                'test' => 'value < 80',
                /* xgettext:no-php-format */
                'issue' => __('Less than 80% of the query cache is being utilized.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'This might be caused by {query_cache_limit} being too low.'
                    . ' Flushing the query cache might help as well.',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    'The current ratio of free query cache memory to total query'
                    . ' cache size is %s%%. It should be above 80%%',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Query cache fragmentation',
                'name' => __('Query cache fragmentation'),
                'precondition' => '!fired(\'Query cache disabled\')',
                'formula' => 'Qcache_free_blocks / (Qcache_total_blocks / 2) * 100',
                'test' => 'value > 20',
                'issue' => __('The query cache is considerably fragmented.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Severe fragmentation is likely to (further) increase Qcache_lowmem_prunes. This might be'
                    . ' caused by many Query cache low memory prunes due to {query_cache_size} being too small. For a'
                    . ' immediate but short lived fix you can flush the query cache (might lock the query cache for a'
                    . ' long time). Carefully adjusting {query_cache_min_res_unit} to a lower value might help too,'
                    . ' e.g. you can set it to the average size of your queries in the cache using this formula:'
                    . ' (query_cache_size - qcache_free_memory) / qcache_queries_in_cache',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    'The cache is currently fragmented by %s%% , with 100%% fragmentation meaning that the query'
                    . ' cache is an alternating pattern of free and used blocks. This value should be below 20%%.',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Query cache low memory prunes',
                'name' => __('Query cache low memory prunes'),
                'precondition' => 'Qcache_inserts > 0 && !fired(\'Query cache disabled\')',
                'formula' => 'Qcache_lowmem_prunes / Qcache_inserts * 100',
                'test' => 'value > 0.1',
                'issue' => __('Cached queries are removed due to low query cache memory from the query cache.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'You might want to increase {query_cache_size}, however keep in mind that the overhead of'
                    . ' maintaining the cache is likely to increase with its size, so do this in small increments'
                    . ' and monitor the results.',
                ),
                'justification' => __(
                    'The ratio of removed queries to inserted queries is %s%%. The lower this value is,'
                    . ' the better (This rules firing limit: 0.1%%)',
                ),
                'justification_formula' => 'round(value,1)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Query cache max size',
                'name' => __('Query cache max size'),
                'precondition' => '!fired(\'Query cache disabled\')',
                'formula' => 'query_cache_size',
                'test' => 'value > 1024 * 1024 * 128',
                'issue' => __(
                    'The query cache size is above 128 MiB. Big query caches may cause significant'
                    . ' overhead that is required to maintain the cache.',
                ),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Depending on your environment, it might be performance increasing to reduce this value.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('Current query cache size: %s'),
                'justification_formula' => 'ADVISOR_formatByteDown(value, 2, 2)',
            ],
            [
                'id' => 'Query cache min result size',
                'name' => __('Query cache min result size'),
                'precondition' => '!fired(\'Query cache disabled\')',
                'formula' => 'query_cache_limit',
                'test' => 'value == 1024*1024',
                'issue' => __('The max size of the result set in the query cache is the default of 1 MiB.'),
                'recommendation' => __(
                    'Changing {query_cache_limit} (usually by increasing) may increase efficiency. This variable'
                    . ' determines the maximum size a query result may have to be inserted into the query cache.'
                    . ' If there are many query results above 1 MiB that are well cacheable (many reads, little writes)'
                    . ' then increasing {query_cache_limit} will increase efficiency. Whereas in the case of many query'
                    . ' results being above 1 MiB that are not very well cacheable (often invalidated due to table'
                    . ' updates) increasing {query_cache_limit} might reduce efficiency.',
                ),
                'justification' => __('query_cache_limit is set to 1 MiB'),
            ],
        ];
    }
}