Tweakphoeus::Client#initialize has boolean parameter 'redirect' Open
def initialize(ua_systems: %i[linux mac], ssl_verifypeer: true, redirect: false)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Boolean Parameter
is a special case of Control Couple
, where a method parameter is defaulted to true or false. A Boolean Parameter effectively permits a method's caller to decide which execution path to take. This is a case of bad cohesion. You're creating a dependency between methods that is not really necessary, thus increasing coupling.
Example
Given
class Dummy
def hit_the_switch(switch = true)
if switch
puts 'Hitting the switch'
# do other things...
else
puts 'Not hitting the switch'
# do other things...
end
end
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
test.rb -- 3 warnings:
[1]:Dummy#hit_the_switch has boolean parameter 'switch' (BooleanParameter)
[2]:Dummy#hit_the_switch is controlled by argument switch (ControlParameter)
Note that both smells are reported, Boolean Parameter
and Control Parameter
.
Getting rid of the smell
This is highly dependent on your exact architecture, but looking at the example above what you could do is:
- Move everything in the
if
branch into a separate method - Move everything in the
else
branch into a separate method - Get rid of the
hit_the_switch
method alltogether - Make the decision what method to call in the initial caller of
hit_the_switch
Tweakphoeus::Client has at least 7 instance variables Open
class Client
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Too Many Instance Variables
is a special case of LargeClass
.
Example
Given this configuration
TooManyInstanceVariables:
max_instance_variables: 3
and this code:
class TooManyInstanceVariables
def initialize
@arg_1 = :dummy
@arg_2 = :dummy
@arg_3 = :dummy
@arg_4 = :dummy
end
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
test.rb -- 5 warnings:
[1]:TooManyInstanceVariables has at least 4 instance variables (TooManyInstanceVariables)
Tweakphoeus::Client#initialize has boolean parameter 'ssl_verifypeer' Open
def initialize(ua_systems: %i[linux mac], ssl_verifypeer: true, redirect: false)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
Boolean Parameter
is a special case of Control Couple
, where a method parameter is defaulted to true or false. A Boolean Parameter effectively permits a method's caller to decide which execution path to take. This is a case of bad cohesion. You're creating a dependency between methods that is not really necessary, thus increasing coupling.
Example
Given
class Dummy
def hit_the_switch(switch = true)
if switch
puts 'Hitting the switch'
# do other things...
else
puts 'Not hitting the switch'
# do other things...
end
end
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
test.rb -- 3 warnings:
[1]:Dummy#hit_the_switch has boolean parameter 'switch' (BooleanParameter)
[2]:Dummy#hit_the_switch is controlled by argument switch (ControlParameter)
Note that both smells are reported, Boolean Parameter
and Control Parameter
.
Getting rid of the smell
This is highly dependent on your exact architecture, but looking at the example above what you could do is:
- Move everything in the
if
branch into a separate method - Move everything in the
else
branch into a separate method - Get rid of the
hit_the_switch
method alltogether - Make the decision what method to call in the initial caller of
hit_the_switch
Tweakphoeus::Client#get has 4 parameters Open
def get(url, body: nil, params: nil, headers: nil)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A Long Parameter List
occurs when a method has a lot of parameters.
Example
Given
class Dummy
def long_list(foo,bar,baz,fling,flung)
puts foo,bar,baz,fling,flung
end
end
Reek would report the following warning:
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[2]:Dummy#long_list has 5 parameters (LongParameterList)
A common solution to this problem would be the introduction of parameter objects.
Tweakphoeus::Client#http_request has 5 parameters Open
def http_request(url, body: nil, params: nil, headers: nil, method: :get)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A Long Parameter List
occurs when a method has a lot of parameters.
Example
Given
class Dummy
def long_list(foo,bar,baz,fling,flung)
puts foo,bar,baz,fling,flung
end
end
Reek would report the following warning:
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[2]:Dummy#long_list has 5 parameters (LongParameterList)
A common solution to this problem would be the introduction of parameter objects.
Tweakphoeus::Client#redirect_url doesn't depend on instance state (maybe move it to another class?) Open
def redirect_url(response)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A Utility Function is any instance method that has no dependency on the state of the instance.
Tweakphoeus::Client#base_headers is a writable attribute Open
attr_accessor :cookie_jar, :referer_list, :base_headers, :redirect
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A class that publishes a setter for an instance variable invites client classes to become too intimate with its inner workings, and in particular with its representation of state.
The same holds to a lesser extent for getters, but Reek doesn't flag those.
Example
Given:
class Klass
attr_accessor :dummy
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
reek test.rb
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[2]:Klass declares the writable attribute dummy (Attribute)
Tweakphoeus::Client#redirect? performs a nil-check Open
!redirect_url(response).nil?
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A NilCheck
is a type check. Failures of NilCheck
violate the "tell, don't ask" principle.
Additionally, type checks often mask bigger problems in your source code like not using OOP and / or polymorphism when you should.
Example
Given
class Klass
def nil_checker(argument)
if argument.nil?
puts "argument isn't nil!"
end
end
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[3]:Klass#nil_checker performs a nil-check. (NilCheck)
Tweakphoeus::Client#build_base_headers doesn't depend on instance state (maybe move it to another class?) Open
def build_base_headers(ua_systems)
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A Utility Function is any instance method that has no dependency on the state of the instance.
Tweakphoeus::Client#cookie_jar is a writable attribute Open
attr_accessor :cookie_jar, :referer_list, :base_headers, :redirect
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A class that publishes a setter for an instance variable invites client classes to become too intimate with its inner workings, and in particular with its representation of state.
The same holds to a lesser extent for getters, but Reek doesn't flag those.
Example
Given:
class Klass
attr_accessor :dummy
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
reek test.rb
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[2]:Klass declares the writable attribute dummy (Attribute)
Tweakphoeus::Client#redirect is a writable attribute Open
attr_accessor :cookie_jar, :referer_list, :base_headers, :redirect
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A class that publishes a setter for an instance variable invites client classes to become too intimate with its inner workings, and in particular with its representation of state.
The same holds to a lesser extent for getters, but Reek doesn't flag those.
Example
Given:
class Klass
attr_accessor :dummy
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
reek test.rb
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[2]:Klass declares the writable attribute dummy (Attribute)
Tweakphoeus::Client takes parameters ['body', 'headers', 'url'] to 4 methods Open
def get(url, body: nil, params: nil, headers: nil)
referer_list.referer_from_headers(headers)
http_request(url, body: body, params: params, headers: headers, method: :get)
end
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
In general, a Data Clump
occurs when the same two or three items frequently appear together in classes and parameter lists, or when a group of instance variable names start or end with similar substrings.
The recurrence of the items often means there is duplicate code spread around to handle them. There may be an abstraction missing from the code, making the system harder to understand.
Example
Given
class Dummy
def x(y1,y2); end
def y(y1,y2); end
def z(y1,y2); end
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[2, 3, 4]:Dummy takes parameters [y1, y2] to 3 methods (DataClump)
A possible way to fix this problem (quoting from Martin Fowler):
The first step is to replace data clumps with objects and use the objects whenever you see them. An immediate benefit is that you'll shrink some parameter lists. The interesting stuff happens as you begin to look for behavior to move into the new objects.
Tweakphoeus::Client#referer_list is a writable attribute Open
attr_accessor :cookie_jar, :referer_list, :base_headers, :redirect
- Read upRead up
- Create a ticketCreate a ticket
- Exclude checks
A class that publishes a setter for an instance variable invites client classes to become too intimate with its inner workings, and in particular with its representation of state.
The same holds to a lesser extent for getters, but Reek doesn't flag those.
Example
Given:
class Klass
attr_accessor :dummy
end
Reek would emit the following warning:
reek test.rb
test.rb -- 1 warning:
[2]:Klass declares the writable attribute dummy (Attribute)